Use the same base geometry
For either material, start with actual tiled surface area.
Separate walls, floors, exterior areas, and different SKUs before allowances.
Let format and layout drive cuts
Large-format porcelain, small ceramic wall tile, mosaics, diagonals, and patterns have different cut behavior.
Do not assign waste solely by porcelain versus ceramic.
Use exact package data
Pieces and square feet per carton vary by product and format.
Procurement should use current SKU packaging.
Verify suitability separately
Products can have different ratings, absorption, finish, slip, substrate, mortar, and exposure requirements.
A correct box count does not establish suitability.
Keep spare stock explicit
Future repair stock is a purchasing choice beyond installation cut allowance.
Record it separately so the takeoff remains auditable.