Fix the geometry first
Calculate the same compacted design volume for each candidate material.
Keep depth and footprint constant when comparing alternatives.
Convert each material separately
Tons = compacted cubic yards × verified supplier conversion for that aggregate.
Source rock, gradation, moisture, and voids influence bulk density.
Compare delivered quantities
Account for compaction and placement allowance explicitly.
Compare delivered cost only after converting both options to the same required compacted volume.
Follow the specification
Base suitability depends on gradation, durability, drainage, and project requirements, not just rock type.
Quantity comparison cannot approve a material substitution.